If you’re a Cleveland homeowner weighing a new roof, new siding, or a kitchen remodel, the question that matters most is simple: will this project actually pay me back? Every year, the Cost vs. Value Report — the remodeling industry’s most widely cited benchmark — answers that question with real numbers, comparing the average cost of 28 common home improvement projects against the value they add at resale, market by market. Here’s what the 2025 data shows for the Cleveland, OH metro area, and what it means if you’re planning a project this year.
What Is the Cost vs. Value Report?
Published annually, the Cost vs. Value Report surveys remodeling contractors and real estate professionals across the country to estimate two numbers for each project: the average job cost in a given metro area, and the value a knowledgeable buyer would likely pay for a home with that improvement already completed. Dividing resale value by job cost gives the “cost recouped” percentage — the figure homeowners and real estate agents use to judge whether a project is a smart investment or more of a personal upgrade. Cleveland has its own line of data in the report, separate from the broader East North Central region and the national average, which makes it one of the few sources that speaks directly to our local market rather than a national generalization.
Cleveland’s Top-Performing Projects for 2025
According to the 2025 report, these exterior projects delivered the strongest return for Cleveland homeowners:
- Garage Door Replacement: $4,085 average cost, $9,596 added resale value — 234.9% cost recouped, the single highest-ROI project in the entire report
- Manufactured Stone Veneer: $11,593 average cost, $22,295 added resale value — 192.3% cost recouped
- Entry Door Replacement, Steel: $2,293 average cost, $4,203 added resale value — 183.3% cost recouped
Notice the pattern: every one of these is a relatively low-cost, high-visibility exterior upgrade. Buyers and appraisers respond strongly to curb appeal, and projects like these change the first impression of a home without requiring a six-figure renovation budget.
How Roofing and Siding Stack Up
Roofing and siding won’t match a garage door’s eye-popping percentage, but the data still tells an important story:
- Siding Replacement, Fiber-Cement: $23,791 average cost, $20,743 added resale value — 87.2% cost recouped
- Siding Replacement, Vinyl: $18,274 average cost, $13,805 added resale value — 75.5% cost recouped
- Roof Replacement, Asphalt Shingles: $26,705 average cost, $18,355 added resale value — 68.7% cost recouped
- Roof Replacement, Metal: $43,762 average cost, $20,847 added resale value — 47.6% cost recouped
A roof or siding replacement recouping less than 100% of its cost doesn’t mean it’s a bad investment — it means the primary return isn’t resale value, it’s protection. An aging roof or failing siding puts the rest of the home at risk of water intrusion, mold, and structural damage, and many buyers simply won’t make an offer on a home that needs one soon. (For a closer look at whether your roof needs a full repair or replacement, or how vinyl compares to fiber-cement siding in our climate, we’ve broken both down in detail.)
Interior Remodels: Kitchens, Baths, and Basements
Interior projects remain popular even when the dollar-for-dollar return is lower than most exterior work:
- Minor Kitchen Remodel, Midrange: $25,895 average cost, $24,398 added resale value — 94.2% cost recouped
- Bathroom Remodel, Midrange: $24,448 average cost, $17,421 added resale value — 71.3% cost recouped
- Basement Remodel: $46,815 average cost, $32,683 added resale value — 69.8% cost recouped
A minor kitchen refresh — new cabinet fronts, countertops, fixtures, and paint, rather than a full gut renovation — consistently outperforms a major kitchen overhaul in cost-recouped terms. If you’re weighing a bathroom project specifically, we cover the cost and ROI breakdown in more detail in our bathroom remodel guide.
What This Means If You’re Planning a Project
A few practical takeaways from this year’s Cleveland data:
- If you’re selling soon, a garage door, entry door, or stone veneer accent delivers the fastest, highest-percentage return for the least amount of disruption.
- If your roof or siding is aging, replacing it protects the home’s value and insurability even though the direct resale return is more modest — think of it as loss prevention as much as value creation.
- If you’re remodeling to stay, a minor kitchen update tends to make more financial sense than a major one, while still giving you a space you’ll enjoy living in.
Every home and budget is different, and the right project for your situation depends on your home’s age, condition, and how long you plan to stay. Our team can walk your property and give you a straightforward, no-pressure estimate for roofing, siding, or remodeling work so you can decide with real numbers in hand — not just a report. Contact ARC Roofing & Home Improvement to schedule a free consultation.
Data source: 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, Cleveland, OH metro market.






